āAn e-bike damaged my car but Forest wonāt pay the Ā£840 repair billā
āAn e-bike damaged my car but Forest wonāt pay the Ā£840 repair billā

Ruth EmerySun, November 15, 2026 at 12:00 PM UTC
0

Luke Brookes
Has a company treated you unfairly? Ruth Emery, our consumer champion, is here to help. To contact Ruth, click here*.
Dear Ruth,
A few months ago, a Forest e-bike parked on a pavement fell and damaged my parked car. It left a curved scrape on the rear passenger door, caused by the handlebar.
I complained to Forest, but it refused to pay for the repair, refused even to inspect the damage, and tried to give me the brush-off.
Ultimately, its argument is that because there is no video of the incident as it happened (an impossible demand, and not one the company makes when its own bikes are damaged), it didnāt happen. I understand this might be an argument in a criminal court, but in civil matters itās a case of balance of probabilities.
The incident took place in the evening, between 8.59pm and 10pm. The next day, when I discovered the damage, I contacted Forest, with full details and photos, and subsequently sent more photos and contact details for a witness. I also contacted the Metropolitan Police (the Met), who gave me a crime number.
I am in the process of obtaining witness statements from the two people who were with me when I discovered the damage to my car and the person who saw the bike sprawled on the pavement beside my car the night before.
I have three quotations from independent garages for repairing the work; I only asked Forest to pay the cheapest, which is £840, because I wish to be reasonable.
Forest is denying liability in spite of my providing copious detail and has sent me a final, patronising response. Before I take this to the small claims court ā an onerous, lengthy and uncertain business ā Iām writing to you in the hope you can bring Forest to its senses.
ā EH, London
Dear Reader,
E-bikes have become the āMarmiteā of Londonās transport network. For those who use them, theyāre a convenient way to zip around the capital. For everyone else (myself included), theyāre a bit of a pest. E-bike riders are surely the most likely out of all road users to run a red light, mount the pavement or park badly.
You live in Islington, and last year the borough said e-bike hire companies Lime and Forest were on their ālast warningā to tackle dangerous parking and poor rider behaviour.
The Government launched a consultation this month proposing national standards for e-biking, which could result in on-the-spot fines for dangerous riding and designated parking areas to keep pavements safe.
In terms of your case, your red Skoda Fabia was parked on the street near your flat. You sent me photos of the Forest e-bike standing on the pavement and the damage to your car.
The tone of your emails to me and to Forest were pure outrage that the e-bike could have dented your vehicle like this. You had reported it to the police, gone door-to-door at neighbouring flats trying to find witnesses and CCTV, and demanded that Forest pay for the repair bill.

The arc-shaped dent in our readerās car
You claim the bike fell and damaged your car. However, there is no evidence of this. As you say, a video of it happening may be a tall order from Forest, but actually no one saw the bike fall or hit your car.
To play devilās advocate, the scratch could have happened at any time. No one can say it was caused by the e-bike or in the time window you suggest.
You argued that your car had a ānew, deep, arc-shaped groove in the rear passenger door, at a height where the handlebar of a falling bike would strikeā, plus there was āan apparent transfer of red paint into the rim of the bikeās handlebarā.
Advertisement
You also said a neighbour saw the bike lying on the ground beside your car at around 10pm, but the next morning the bike was standing up. Forest had told you the e-bike was parked at 8.59pm the previous evening, hence your belief that the incident occurred between 8.59pm and 10pm.
The best way to prove what happened was with video footage. I asked the Met whether it had obtained CCTV after you reported the crime, but it said it could only assist journalists with individual incidents that involve āthe highest levels of threat, risk and harmā.
So, I contacted Savills, the property manager of your block of flats, to see if it had CCTV that looked out on to the road. Savills said it only retained CCTV footage for 30 days, and this timeframe had been and gone. Furthermore, it said the Met Police had never requested it.
I also phoned the garage which had examined the dent and quoted Ā£840 to fix it. Could it say, in their professional opinion, that the damage was new and potentially caused by a heavy e-bikeās handlebar? Unfortunately, I never heard back from the garage.
I must say that while this e-bike could have fallen on your car, your complaint to Forest is all based on conjecture.
When Iām not helping Telegraph readers, Iām a magistrate, so your point about criminal vs civil court is interesting. Iām used to looking at things through a lens of ābeyond reasonable doubtā, which applies to criminal courts. Civil courts use a lower standard known as the ābalance of probabilitiesā.
However, instead of taking Forest to court, what about claiming on your car insurance? But, you say you donāt want to do this in case it increases your premiums in future.
You complained to your three councillors: maybe they could apply some pressure to Forest, and you also wanted your complaint recorded by Islington council as part of its review into having e-bike operators in the borough. However, you didnāt get a satisfactory response.
I also called and emailed the council several times to see whether it had any CCTV and to find out what it thought of Forest generally, and whether it had any advice for residents who say their property has been damaged by an e-bike. No one bothered to get back to me.
At this point, Iād hit a dead end, and it was time to see what Forest had to say. I asked the e-bike company if it could contact the person who had ridden the bike to see if they remembered the bike falling over. Also, was the bike even allowed to be parked on the pavement?
Forest said the bike was allowed to be parked in that area and that it had checked the status of the rider. Apparently the customer was a regular user who has completed more than 300 rides and has never incurred any fines or penalties for poor parking behaviour.
It added that it would not contact the rider as there was no evidence of wrongdoing on their part and that it would need āclear evidence before we could consider paying compensationā.
Youāre grateful for my help, but remain astounded that Forest wonāt fork out the Ā£840. āWhat remotely feasible, let alone realistic, alternative explanation can they suggest for the damage to my car, given the proximity of their heavy e-bike, other than the bike falling on it and the handlebar causing this arc-shaped gouge?ā you asserted.
You intend to take Forest to the small claims court, armed with a signed witness statement that you have obtained from a neighbour. The witness says she saw a bike lying on the ground next to a red Skoda Fabia between 9.45 and 10pm.
She has a walking stick and was distressed she had to navigate her way around this obstacle, which she called a ātrip hazardā. She described it as a āgusty eveningā. She saw the scrape and dent in the Skodaās door panel and assumed the bike had toppled on to the car, and the damage had been caused by the handlebar or brake handle.
I admire your perseverance and suspect the witness statement may well tip the balance of probabilities in your favour at court.
ā Ruth
*Please note that by submitting your content to us, you are consenting to The Telegraph processing your personal data where required by law. For further details, please see our Privacy Notice.
Source: āAOL Moneyā