Book Lovers Reveal The Classic Novels That Don't Deserve The Hype
Book Lovers Reveal The Classic Novels That Don't Deserve The Hype

Abby ZinmanMon, November 16, 2026 at 2:31 AM UTC
0

I'm a huge book lover, and always have been. This means one thing: I have very strong (and often controversial) opinions on popular novels. Whenever it came time to read the classics in English class, I was a harsh critic, and wasn't afraid to spit out my unpopular opinions.So recently, we asked the bookworms of the BuzzFeed Community, "Which 'classic' book doesn't deserve that title?" and people responded with some extremely hot — and admittedly convincing — takes. Get ready to fight for your faves, because here we go...
Additional responses were found in this Reddit thread.

Paramount Pictures / Everett Collection1. "I don't understand why The Catcher in the Rye is a classic. A spoiled college kid does nothing. I don't see any point in that story. Holden Caulfield is insufferable."
—hunnybunnyfuntime
"I read it in my sophomore year of high school, and our whole class loved it so much, except me. I was like, 'Holden is insufferable and makes his past traumas everyone else's problem; what about this do y'all love so much?'
To this day, I'm still wondering what the rest of my English class saw in that book other than possibly the compelling way our teacher read it out loud."
—thespritepepsi
"It's a different kind of classic, I suppose, because I didn't find it beautifully written. Maybe a classic bore or a classic waste of a read."
—mcnallyjoy777

MANDEL NGAN / Getty Images2. "The Scarlet Letter. It's only 200 pages, but it feels longer. It's nothing but a slog through pure shame, guilt, self-flagellation (I'm being quite literal here), and despair. Nathaniel Hawthorne's great-great-granddaddy was a judge in the Salem witch trials, and he morosely continues to make that the reader's problem even today. Do not recommend."
—torty
"This is an excellent review, even if my melodramatic ass loves The Scarlet Letter."
—francesjoys
Related: "Test Your IQ: 17 Idioms Only The Smartest People Can Know Correctly"
3. "The Great Gatsby... It is sooo boring! I have literally tried to get through it so many times and can't. Thank god for SparkNotes!"
—heroicchinchilla853
"It took me three months to get past the first chapter, which I had to do, because it was required reading for school."
—shinypumpkin83
"So glad to see people saying The Great Gatsby. I cannot understand the love for this book.
Having been assigned it three times — once in high school and twice in college — I just do not see why it's considered the 'quintessential American novel.'"
—wanderingstorm

Oli Scarff / Getty Images4. "Pride and Prejudice. I have read it twice and have been informed at length of its manifold merits. I am usually an advocate of detailed, flowery prose, but I could not condone the sheer verbosity I encountered in this novel. The psychological depth was perfunctory at best. I would say the only remotely interesting character was Mr. Collins, whom I think is rather tragic and satirizes the stiff, hypocritical hauteur of aristocratic society. I struggled to empathize with the other characters due to them seeming like caricatures."
—apexfOOl
5. "I could go on a long, long rant on why 1984 isn’t that great, not realistic at all, and people should stop praising it for being that. A whole lot of people think dystopias or evil governments can only look like 1984, which, unironically, is counterproductive. The writing of it isn't even that good. The best dystopias are the ones that look like utopias at first glance; that's what makes them dangerous. Everyone can tell a comically evil authoritarian regime is evil."
—randompersononplanet
"1984 is a dull read. The underpinning ideas are riveting, but it is a tough read. Orwell's essays in general are excellent, however, and Animal Farm is a fun read."
—omartron2020

AARON TAM / AFP via Getty Images6. "The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho is, without a doubt, the worst book I have ever read. A collection of reheated clichés wrapped in pseudo-mystical packaging. The plot is so predictable it could have been written by a horoscope generator; the characters are flatter than a paperback left out in the rain, and the so-called wisdom consists of fortune-cookie philosophy dressed up as revelation. I really do not get the hype."
—Heidi-Silke
"The Alchemist makes The Da Vinci Code seem profound. Not a compliment to either book."
—NatsFan8447
7. "Dune. I only read the first novel because I was told it had great 'world-building.' I found the characters utterly unappealing and came away thinking there was really nothing of a story. And don't get me started on the hero being tested in single combat — TWICE. It's not dramatic; it's just lazy writing. I was happy when the book ended, and really wished Paul died just to satisfy me by ending such a waste of my time. The only thing I thought even remotely interesting was the way the myth was implanted into the collective memories of the planet's citizens."
—gobsmacked1

Bill Tompkins / Getty Images8. "I read all the time, usually a book or two a week. But I could not get through Catch-22. The Grapes of Wrath is rough, too."
—youngsword114
"I found the pacing bizarre and felt really bored most of the time.
The last 200 pages were a slog. Also, just in general, I had trouble following what was going on."
—Apprehensive-Bed-188
Advertisement
9. "The Bell Jar. Yes, I do 'get it.' It just didn’t hit me or particularly wow me, despite my past mental health issues. It’s a fine story about a depressed woman, and that’s just it."
—reputction
10. "Little Women. Horrible book. Just dull and dreary."
—mizk23

Buyenlarge / Getty Images11. "The Outsider by Albert Camus. It's meant to be existential and thought-provoking, but in my opinion, it only serves to show how insufferable the main character is."
—fluffyghoul1435
12. "Crime and Punishment and The Brothers Karamazov. Actually, most of Dostoevsky’s work. I can’t stand his writing style. I've heard many say that his characters are realistically portrayed, which, in my opinion, is far from the truth; his characters are mad people who often burst out in boring theatrical monologues. Maybe I’m just not angsty or depressed enough for Dostoevsky."
—NeedleworkerNo2818

Bill Tompkins / Getty Images13. "The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway was so tedious and boring, I wanted to gouge my eyes out so I wouldn't have to read it. It was required reading for me in my high school English class."
—jennyjsj
"My nemesis in book form is The Old Man and the Sea. Everyone LOVES that book, and I just want to know if we read the same thing.
Beyond boring, it aggravated me beyond belief, and you feel every one of its 127 pages. Just brutal, and seeing it on the shelf makes me rage."
—NeatSpec
14. "I know that I'm in the minority here, but The Hobbit. I've never been so bored in my life."
—ellie4me

Bill Tompkins / Getty Images15. "Finnegans Wake by James Joyce. I feel trolled by its very existence."
—joyfulvolcano264
16. "I really didn’t like A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man by James Joyce. Maybe I’m just too dumb, but I really did not care about anything going on in that book."
—xbrooksie
17. "Moby-Dick. It is less about a man's obsession with the hunt and more about the ins-and-outs of mid-19th century whaling. I was expecting a gripping tale of a man's madness and got a how-to on how to kill, catch, and cut up whales."
—songjihyofan
"I tried multiple times to read it and couldn't get past the second page. Ugh."
—beachgirl2023

JannHuizenga / Getty Images18. "This isn't a classic — perhaps a modern classic — but The Song of Achilles. Nothing in the world fills me with an inferno of rage like The Song of Achilles. As a queer guy myself, it felt super stereotypical, especially because the women were basically used as yaoi trope devices. Some people like that kind of dramatic mood, but definitely not me."
—what-a-stupid-bucket
19. "I couldn't get through Wuthering Heights when I tried reading it years ago. The writing seemed oddly clumsy and childish to me. To be fair, it was a Spanish translation, although a reputable one. Maybe I would change my mind if I read it in English."
—rausrausfilafila
20. "In my sophomore year English class, we could choose between Les Miserables and The Count of Monte Cristo. I chose Les Mis. I chose wrong."
—savoryorc274
"I get the scope. I get the message. I even get the writing, and I used to be fluent enough to have read some of it in French (I’d already read it in English and hadn’t been impressed; I wanted to make sure it wasn’t the translation). It’s all good. I have to praise him as I should.
But Jesus on a pony, why didn’t anyone edit that damn doorstop?"
—forkicksforgood

Apic / Getty Images21. "Siddhartha. I love Hermann Hesse, but that book was Jung if he wrote a novel, without psychological jargon. I loved its prose, but I couldn't get this idea outta my head."
—NooraldeenHA12
22. "Gulliver's Travels. The first two parts were exactly what I signed up for: classic adventures while also examining arbitrary rules and governmental systems. By the end, it is a nihilistic philosophical treatise where he comes to the conclusion that humanity is incorrigibly evil; it is weird and depressing, and it took everything I had to keep reading it."
—RETVRN1776

Culture Club / Getty Images23. "If you want kids to learn to love reading, let them read books that appeal to them. Even if you have the additional goal of getting them to think about the world, a lot of classics are too densely written about times they know nothing about. If you want to take a 'great books' course, by all means, read them to understand the history of literature. As for which books we're all supposed to read, actually, suck. A lot of your 'great American novels,' the size of a brick, written by straight white men, are pretty awful: Tom Wolfe, Philip Roth, Jonathan Franzen, Saul Bellow — never read a really enjoyable book by any of them."
—jens4b88bfecd
24. "I didn't care for A Tale of Two Cities — I couldn't get past the first 20 pages."
—officialshield595

Bill Tompkins / Getty Images25. "All Quiet on the Western Front. I'm sure that last one was groundbreaking, especially for its time, but the prose was so boring. And I'm an avid reader."
—spoilsofwar
26. "It saddens me, but Madame Bovary did very little for me. A series of wonderful descriptions that fail to amount to more than the sum of their parts. I’m surely missing something and will return one day to read it in the original."
—maybeimaleo

DEA PICTURE LIBRARY / Getty Images27. "I think the book To Kill a Mockingbird, because it mentions a mockingbird, like, twice...no real relevance whatsoever."
—mikonsio
28. And lastly, "Any book by Charles Dickens — except for A Christmas Carol. That one is good."
—hurricane7

Culture Club / Bridgeman via Getty ImagesYikes, these were some hot takes. I'm only a tad offended.What's a classic book you think is extremely overrated? Don't be shy — share your response in this quick anonymous form, or in the comments below!
Your daily brain workout: Can You Finish This Easy, One-Level Word Chain?
Read it on BuzzFeed.com
Source: “AOL Entertainment”