ShowBiz & Sports Lifestyle

Hot

Downstate review – razor-sharp tragicomedy set in a home for sex offenders

Downstate review – razor-sharp tragicomedy set in a home for sex offenders

Owen Myers Mon, November 16, 2026 at 3:02 AM UTC

0

Thomas Sadoski and K Todd Freeman in Downstate.Photograph: Emilio Madrid

Fred doesn’t get out much these days, thanks to the incident that put him in a wheelchair. But the elderly man finds joy in small things: the music of Chopin, fruity smoothies prepared by his doting housemate Dee, as well as Nutter Butter cookies. Not everyone sees Fred as harmless. Minutes after we meet him, a man a few decades his junior tells him that he is a fundamentally evil person and describes in cold, chilling detail exactly how he would carry out his murder.

Related: Wanted review – generic crime musical lacks outlaw grit

Fred is one of four registered sex offenders whose life in a group home is the subject of Downstate, a razor-sharp black comedy by playwright Bruce Norris. As well as Fred (Frances Guinan), the house residents include buff gym rat Gio (Al’Jaleel McGhee), taciturn Felix (Adrian Martinez) and the thespy, Diana Ross-obsessed Dee (K Todd Freeman), a surrogate caretaker for the old man. The men have been somewhat thrown together as an unlikely family, and the yellowing wallpaper and mismatched furniture has certainly seen better days. But the spot is a comfortable enough place for the men to land, although the baseball bat propped up by the front door shows that they are ready for violence if it comes their way.

After premiering in Chicago in 2018, the play moved to New York’s Playwrights Horizons for an off-Broadway premiere in 2022, where it became swept up in a flurry of culture war nonsense after Texas senator Ted Cruz slammed a positive Washington Post review for ā€œpraising pedophiliaā€. That review didn’t, and neither does Downstate itself. But the play does do the still-radical thing of showing sex offenders as human beings and not as cartoon bogeymen.

This new Broadway version, steered by the veteran director Joe Mantello (Wicked, this year’s Death of a Salesman) is a pyrotechnic display of acting prowess. Liza Colón-Zayas is electric as Ivy, a peace officer looking after, and out for, the men. Her job is often thankless, and The Bear actor embodies the wariness of someone who has learned the hard way that her empathy may be read as weakness. She deeply cares for her charges, even as she wearies of their complaints after they are banned from a local grocery store thanks to its proximity to a school. ā€œIf y’all feel victimized, maybe that gives you a taste of how other people feel,ā€ she snaps.

Advertisement

Downstate is billed as a tragicomedy, and its humor is as grim as a walk to the gallows – but wickedly funny all the same. At one point, one character questions the au courant descriptor of those who have suffered sexual abuse as ā€œsurvivorsā€. ā€œNot a lotta cases of death by blowjob,ā€ he says.

The play constantly toys with your loyalties, embracing murky grey areas around consent and coercion. It’s hard not to feel for Dee as he breaks down while describing the ā€œloveā€ he felt for a 14-year-old boy, even if the brutal facts of his abuse are impossible to ignore. Meanwhile, the story of Frank sexually abusing his own daughter may make you feel that no sentence would be too severe (how could the punishment ever fit the crime?). Still another resident was inside on a statutory charge. ā€œI’m level one and you’ve lumped me in with the level three,ā€ complains Gio, referring to risk classifications of child sex offenders.

Related: A Few Good Men review – Aaron Sorkin’s legal drama makes unwelcome return to stage

Downstate is a blistering examination of what being treated as scum does to a person’s psyche. As the play reaches its crescendo, the man from the opening scene (Thomas Sadoski) returns in the hope of closure for his ā€œassault by a serial predatorā€. Dee has a rather different framing of the incident. ā€œWhat’s the big deal? You had your dick sucked.ā€

With lines as nasty as this, it seemed that all the air had gone from the auditorium at multiple points. Downstate shows that these four sex offenders crave bitter revenge on a world that has kicked them to the curb. This production is nuanced enough that you feel why they would.

Downstate is at the Booth theatre, New York City, until 10 January 2027

Original Article on Source

Source: ā€œAOL Entertainmentā€

We do not use cookies and do not collect personal data. Just news.