ShowBiz & Sports Lifestyle

Hot

Pupils say school mobile phone ban 'stopped us messing about'

Pupils say school mobile phone ban 'stopped us messing about'

Katy McCloskey - BBC ScotlandMon, November 16, 2026 at 6:38 AM UTC

0

Harry from Belmont Academy said the ban helped him to focus on his work

As the bell sounds to announce the start of third period, teachers at Belmont Academy are stationed all along the corridor, manning their classroom doors with big plastic boxes.

The pupils say good morning and as part of a "phone-free classroom" policy, they then deposit their phones in a rectangular foam slot within the box before entering the room.

The box is then locked away until the lesson is over.

"It's genuinely been the best thing we've ever done", says Lynsey Pollock, the principal teacher of social subjects at the school in Ayr.

At Belmont Academy, phones go into a box at the start of lessons and are retrieved at the end

The policy was introduced two years ago, but could be set to change after the Scottish government considers how to implement restrictions on phones in schools.

Legislation will be passed next year and a consultation on the views of parents, pupils and teachers closes at midnight on Tuesday.

For sixth year pupil, Harry, the policy came in at "the perfect time" for him, when he was going into S4 in August 2024.

"I stopped messing around in class, tried to start focusing," he said.

"I was a bit reluctant at first... I'd try and find any way not to put my phone in the box.

"But then I realised: I needed to actually start studying, things were getting important."

Since then, Harry says he's been keeping to that pattern.

Antonia says the ban has made her refocus and re-learn her attitude to her phone

Antonia is also in sixth year.

She remembers when classes were a bit more chaotic before the policy came in.

"I remember all the different notifications always going off. Whenever you hear the notification, you want to go and pick up your phone," she said.

"When we introduced the policy, I didn't have an issue putting my phone in the box."

She feels it has had a positive benefit elsewhere in her life.

"Over time, you condition your brain into being like, 'this is my focus time'. So I think it has really helped separate the working time to the relaxation time."

Antonia feels like she is "unlearning" what she learned as a child about phones.

Pupils at this school can still use phones between classes, but not during class.

There are exceptions for pupils who have specific needs or health conditions, by agreement with the school and pupils.

School captain Emma can see the difference throughout the school day.

Advertisement

She said: "Looking around the tables at lunch, a lot of people actually aren't on their phones and they're all kind of having conversations which is really, really nice."

Ethan, the self-confessed phone addict, accepts his phone use is something he has to work on

One pupil who was not happy about the policy is self-confessed "phone addict" Ethan.

The 17-year-old said: "I'm not afraid to admit it, I am addicted to my phone," he says.

"I know it's something I need to improve on and the phone policy has helped me with that but if I'm going to be honest, I have not enjoyed it."

Ethan does concede that the policy has helped him focus and improved his results.

Headteacher Kevin Boyd said the school decided to make changes as learning was being disrupted by young people constantly looking at their mobile phones.

Headteacher Kevin Boyd said a full ban would be too negative

One of the school's teachers made a video with the pupils of how often they were checking notifications on their phones.

Kevin said: "When we watched that back we realized how often they went to Snapchat, TikTok, Instagram, and that was really disrupting their learning."

The box system is working well, he says, because pupils still have access to phones during the day.

Drummond High School used magnetic locking pouches which secure the phones and release them, similar to how clothing security tags work in shops

In the coming months, ministers will be looking at the impact of policies like Belmont Academy's and contrasting it with more extreme policy, such as phone bans with the use of lockable phone pouches, which have been rolled out in the Edinburgh council area since the end of October.

Young people in Drummond High School are amongst the first in Scotland to lock their phones into pouches at the start of the day.

They can't access them until the final bell goes, when they reach for a special magnet outside the school entrance to open them.

Katie, 14, said: "They have definitely helped people not go on their phones at class time, so I think people are a bit more focused but I do think it also sometimes stops communication."

Katie and Kingjohn have been using the locked pouches at school

Although 12-year-old Kingjohn said it was not always quick to get phones out of pouches at the end of the day.

"It's crowded and there's a limited amount of magnets to use the phone pouches on," he said.

Steven Russell teaches PE at Balerno High, where the pouches were installed just over a week ago.

He told BBC Scotland: "We are trying to create a learning climate where people are able to focus, be present and be engaged in what they are doing.

"At breaktimes and lunchtimes the kids are conversing with each other. Walking down the corridors, there's kids playing Uno. Kids can be kids again."

Education secretary Màiri McAllan said she would encourage anyone with an interest to complete the consultation before midnight on Tuesday.

"Evidence of the risks mobile phones can pose to young people - from school disruption and sleep issues to bullying, harassment and radicalisation - is clear.

"So, too, are the calls from teachers to limit their disruption in class.

"We are treating online harms as a public health issue and schools have an important part to play."

Phones banned in Edinburgh schools - but still no pouches to keep them in

Original Article on Source

Source: “AOL Breaking”

We do not use cookies and do not collect personal data. Just news.