“The Chosen” lawsuit explained: Why investors are suing the hit series’ studio
“The Chosen” lawsuit explained: Why investors are suing the hit series’ studio

Emma MaddenSun, November 15, 2026 at 12:45 PM UTC
0

Jonathan Roumie as Jesus on ‘The Chosen’ alongside members of the cast who play his disciplesCredit: Prime VideoKey Points -
The Chosen investor Christopher Garabedian sued 5&2 Studios over its buyout of more than 16,000 minority shareholders.
The lawsuit alleges the studio undervalued the company and unfairly paid investors $3.75 per share.
The Chosen creator Dallas Jenkins has denied wrongdoing, and the lawsuit is not expected to affect the show’s release schedule.
For five seasons, The Chosen has followed the life and ministry of Jesus Christ, telling the story through the eyes of the people around him. Created by Dallas Jenkins and starring Jonathan Roumie as Jesus, the faith-based historical drama has become a global phenomenon, evolving from an independently financed project into one of the most successful crowdfunded television series ever made.
That unconventional funding model is now at the center of a legal dispute. An early investor in a predecessor to 5&2 Studios, the production company behind The Chosen, is suing the company, alleging that thousands of minority shareholders were unfairly cashed out of their investments just as the series was approaching its greatest commercial potential.
The controversy comes as The Chosen approaches its final chapters: Season 6 premieres on Prime Video on Nov. 15, while the seventh and final season is already in postproduction. Here’s what to know about the lawsuit, the allegations against 5&2, and what the dispute means for the show’s future.
Why is The Chosen facing a lawsuit?

Jesus and his disciples gathered for the Last Supper in season 5 of ‘The Chosen’Credit: Prime Video
The lawsuit centers on whether 5&2 Studios paid its smaller investors a fair price when it took the company private.
In March 2026, the studio carried out what’s known as a “reverse stock split,” which combines a large number of existing shares into fewer new ones. Under the plan, every 173,750 old shares became one new share. Anyone who owned fewer than 173,750 shares had their stock canceled and received $3.75 for each original share.
The move eliminated more than 16,000 minority shareholders, clearing the way for 5&2 to end its public reporting requirements and operate as a private company.
Investor Christopher Garabedian isn’t buying it. His lawsuit alleges that 5&2 undervalued the company and used the stock split to force smaller shareholders out at an unfairly low price. He also argues that the studio scheduled the shareholder vote during Holy Week, potentially discouraging participation at a time when many investors would be focused on religious observances and family. The complaint says more than three-quarters of Series B shareholders did not vote.
How was The Chosen originally funded?

Jonathan Roumie as Jesus in ‘The Chosen’ season 5Credit: Courtesy of Prime Video
Before The Chosen became a global entertainment phenomenon, it was an unusually ambitious crowdfunding project.
Unlike the more familiar crowdfunding model in which supporters simply donate money, these funders were purchasing stock, giving them an actual ownership stake in the business. The campaign raised around $11 million to help finance the show’s first season.
Among those early backers was Garabedian, who became the company’s largest individual crowdfunding investor and served as a co-executive producer on the first season.
The financial model subsequently evolved. After the first season, production was supported through licensing fees and contributions to the Come and See Foundation, a nonprofit organization that raises money to help finance the series and expand its international distribution.
What are the investors alleging?
Garabedian filed a proposed class-action lawsuit in Delaware’s Court of Chancery on June 23, 2026. He alleges that 5&2 improperly bought out more than 16,000 minority shareholders at a price that significantly undervalued the company, allowing insiders to consolidate ownership ahead of the show’s final seasons and potential future projects.
Advertisement
Garabedian is asking the court to award former shareholders the difference between the $3.75 they received per share and what he argues their shares were actually worth.
What has The Chosen creator Dallas Jenkins said about the lawsuit?

Dallas Jenkins on the set of ‘The Chosen’Credit: Prime Video
The studio’s leadership, including Jenkins, has strongly denied any wrongdoing.
In a statement to the New York Times in July, Jenkins said: “We’ve been transparent and accountable from the moment we formed our company and have gone above and beyond to follow all legal and financial requirements.”
He continued, “Any suggestion of impropriety is categorically false, and the full record thoroughly addresses every concern. We’re eager for the court’s review to affirm that.”
The case remains pending in Delaware’s Court of Chancery.
How will the lawsuit affect The Chosen?
Fortunately for fans, the immediate answer appears to be: not much.
Since the lawsuit concerns the financial structure and ownership of 5&2 Studios, rather than the production or creative direction of The Chosen, there is currently no indication that it will interrupt the series’ planned release schedule.
Season 6 premieres on Prime Video on Nov. 15, 2026, with three episodes debuting at once and subsequent episodes arriving weekly through Dec. 6. The season follows Jesus’ final 24 hours, with the crucifixion itself set to be depicted in a standalone theatrical release on March 12, 2027.
And the seventh and final season is already well underway. Filming wrapped in late September, with Jenkins confirming that editing is in progress. In October, the Come and See Foundation announced that Season 7 had reached its $78 million funding goal, thanks to more than 86,000 supporters across 175 countries. Production of all seven seasons is fully funded.
Get your daily dose of entertainment news, celebrity updates, and what to watch with our EW Dispatch newsletter.
In other words, the legal battle is unlikely to prevent viewers from seeing the conclusion of the series. What remains unsettled is the question of who should benefit financially from the extraordinary success of a show that began with thousands of ordinary fans investing in its vision.
Where can I watch The Chosen?
The Chosen is currently available to stream on Prime Video and for free through the show’s official app.
on Entertainment Weekly
Source: “AOL Entertainment”