âThe Gilded Ageâ: How DenĂ©e Benton Fought for Peggyâs Wedding
âThe Gilded Ageâ: How DenĂ©e Benton Fought for Peggyâs Wedding

Kelli BoyleMon, November 16, 2026 at 3:00 AM UTC
0

Jordan Donica as William and Denée Benton as Peggy in 'The Gilded Age' Season 4 Episode 3 - Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
DenĂ©e Bentonâs Peggy Scott has grown from supporting character to leading lady in The Gilded Age, and Season 4 Episode 3 delivered a beautiful series high for the character through her wedding to Dr. William Kirkland (Jordan Donica). Benton tells TV Insider that there was a time during the creation of The Gilded Age Season 4 when the team questioned if they would show Peggyâs wedding at all. Warning: The Gilded Age spoilers ahead.
Benton says she fought for Peggyâs wedding to be shown this season as opposed to the story jumping ahead to after they were wed. Given that, she really wanted the wedding âto have time to lingerâ so viewers could see the happy day radiate. The day before the wedding, plus the wedding itself, were shown in splendid fashion. The set design was like a bright, lush painting. Audra McDonald and Cynthia Nixon share what they love about the wedding in our Gilded Age Aftershow video above, revealing that they were filming the wedding when the New York Knicks won the NBA finals this summer.
Benton explains why the celebratory day almost didnât happen and why she fought for it.
âThereâs so much to get through in our show and thereâs so many storylines that I think originally they were going back and forth about whether or not they were going to show the wedding or if Peggy and William were just going to be married,â Benton reveals. âMe and a couple other people were like, âYou have to have a wedding.'â

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
Peggy has been married once before, but she eloped and the marriage was annulled. That relationship resulted in a child. Peggy was led to believe that the baby boy was stillborn, but the baby was alive. Peggyâs father, Arthur (John Douglas Thompson), arranged for him to be adopted, but he died of scarlet fever a few years later along with his adoptive mother. Benton wanted Peggy to be able to have a moment of pure joy with her wedding after such difficult hardships in the past.
âPeggy has been such a rooted-for underdog, crowd favorite that I feel like the audience has been really waiting for her to get her real center-stage moment,â Benton says. âAnd so I think that itâs a really special pay off that we get to see a full [wedding] sequence.â
The wedding also gives a satisfying conclusion to the fractured family bonds between Peggy and her parents after the ordeal with her first marriage and her late son.

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
Dorothy (McDonald) and Arthur got to finally see their daughter get married, and Peggy got to have moments of healing with her mom and dad as her mom helped her get ready for the ceremony and her dad expressed his love and gratitude before walking her down the aisle. With this closure, the Scott family can move forward even stronger in this next stage of their lives.
Related
'The Gilded Age': Morgan Spector Explains George's Shocking Revenge
Peggy forged a closer bond with her mother-in-law, Elizabeth Kirkland (Phylicia Rashad), the day before the wedding.
Elizabeth was outraged that Peggy and William wanted to jump over a broom in their wedding ceremony. Before slavery ended in America, enslaved people were not legally allowed to get married. The tradition of jumping over a broom to signify a marital union developed as a result. Thatâs how Arthur, who was born into slavery, and Dorothy tied the knot before they had an official ceremony after the Civil War ended, as Arthur explained in this episode.
Arthur and Dorothy gave their wedding broom to Peggy and William, which they accepted happily. Peggyâs cousin, Ava (Adrienne Warren), also brought Nashvilleâs Fisk Jubilee Singers (a real choir plucked from history) to sing during the wedding ceremony.

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
The Kirklands pride themselves on not having familial connections to slavery, and Elizabeth was horrified at the idea of these customs being incorporated into her sonâs wedding.
The Scott and Kirkland disagreements devolved to the point where William told his mother not to come to the wedding if she couldnât accept and love Peggy and her family. Peggy took matters into her own hands in a private conversation with Elizabeth. She told her that William was raised well by his parents and because of that, he would side with his wife in family conflicts. Elizabeth could be in her sonâs life or not, but the choice was entirely hers.
Advertisement
Benton explains what made Peggy so confident in this moment and how her relationship with William informed that.
âPeggy has gone through so much sacrifice at this point in her story over the last four seasons, and she really has found an equal who wants the same things as her and who values the parts of her that are considered taboo in society as an ambitious woman,â Benton says.

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
âShe plays nice for as long as she can, and then she gets to meet Mrs. Kirkland with some of her own alpha medicine and is like, âIâm going to be the head of my own household, and you can be a part of it or not, but Iâm not messing up my soft-life moment for you. We tried,'â she continues.
âI also think that Peggy has a hard line when it comes to the respect she has for her culture and her family, which has been a through-line of what her values are,â Benton adds, âand sheâs really willing to speak truth to power when she has to.â
Peggyâs family traditions are âreally sacred stuff,â Benton notes, and arenât something sheâs willing to sacrifice for anyone. This speaks to Peggyâs belief that her past is not a problem, a concept that other characters in The Gilded Age have to fight against as well âat a time where you have so many characters that are lying about who they were in order to move up in their station,â Benton explains.

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
âYou have Enid Winterton; you have Jack trying to hide where he came from; you have Bertha Russell. In Season 1, they say she was a potato diggerâs daughter,â she says. âThe American way at that time was really to absorb any of your ethnic or indigenous cultural heritage that wasnât this very strict, high society version of American whiteness.
âTo have Peggy be a character whoâs like, âNo, I want you to know where my family came from and how hard they fought to get here,â sheâs like a new version in that era where it could have hindered her rising,â the actress continues, âbut instead, she chooses to show us a version of what it means to carry your history with you.â
More Broadway history was on set in this episode with the addition of Warren, the latest of many Tony winners in The Gilded Age cast. Warrenâs Ava is a member of the Fisk Jubilee Singers. They sang the Gospel songs âMy Lord, What a Morningâ and âAinât That Good Newsâ during the ceremony in Reverend Frederick Kirklandâs (Brian Stokes Mitchell) church.

Karolina Wojtasik/HBO
âIt was really cool getting to be on set with all of my Broadway comrades,â Benton, an alum of Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, says. âAdrienne Warren is a legend of this industry and the American stage, and so her playing my cousin and getting to sing in that moment was really special.â
Related
'The Gilded Age' Cast Explains Season 4 Premiere's Biggest Moments
âBeing in that church, surrounded by all of that original Tiffany glass, hearing songs written by people from that time, it really felt transportingâ Benton shares, âand was just like a moment of celebration and arrival for this world in our show that wasnât necessarily intended to take up as much space as it has. The audience responding so beautifully to it has given us space to keep expanding this world of the Gilded-verse. Iâm thankful to get to be the face of it.â
Weâre breaking down each episode of Season 4 in video interviews with the cast in our Gilded Age Aftershow, the third episode of which you can watch in the video above or on TV Insiderâs YouTube channel. New interviews come out each Sunday this season after the episodes air on HBO.
The Gilded Age, Sundays, 9/8c, HBO
Watch the full video on TV Insider.
Read the latest entertainment news on TV Insider.
Source: âAOL Entertainmentâ